Skip to content
Thursday, November 12, 2026
Discover expert insights on casino games, sports betting st…

The Top Ten Picks from Magic's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Set, According to a Die-Hard Fan Who's Never Played Magic

This forthcoming crossover set for MTG inspired by Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has not yet hit shelves, but it's currently stirring up tremendous excitement. Packed with gorgeous illustrations showcasing various iterations of the heroes, the set draw from everything from the comic books to classic cartoons, movies, and even obscure toys.

If you are a devotee of the half-shell heroes who additionally enjoys Magic: The Gathering, this is the time you've been waiting for. But we have fans like me. As a die-hard TMNT fanatic captivated for decades, that has zero knowledge about the first thing about the card game. Not once have I played a hand. Yet, I'm thrilled about this crossover. My excitement stems from a deep love for the franchise and the rich history showcased on these pieces of cardstock. I love them to such a degree that I've curated the top ten cards in the entire set, ranked exclusively on their "cool factor" of TMNT history. Are they any good in an actual game? I have no idea, and they're in the dark. My only disappointment is the noticeable absence of any reference to the legendary Coming Out of Their Shells tour, which feels like a big oversight.

10. Path to Exile

Art from the original TMNT comic featuring April O'Neil

The image on this card is pulled straight from the 11th issue of the first comic series, showcasing co-creator Kevin Eastman's initial design of April O'Neil. This version is an frequently referenced example of character history, showcasing her later look into a brunette reporter in a yellow jumpsuit from the animated series.

9. A Nod to Video Game History

TMNT arcade game electrocution scene

Like several other cards, Shellshock is a direct homage to classic TMNT arcade titles. In the first arcade game, the Turtles could be electrocuted by a robot named Roadkill Rodney, resulting in a comical visual gag that is exactly recreated here. This moment became a signature element in subsequent games and was even turned into an action figure in 2020.

8. Tempestra, Dame of Games

Card art for the obscure TMNT villain Tempestra

We must take a moment to acknowledge that a card was created based on Tempestra, a mostly forgotten single-episode antagonist from a 1990 episode of the cartoon. In the notable episode, Leonardo becomes obsessed with a video game featuring this digital foe, who is brought to life during an electrical storm. While the episode may not be considered a masterpiece, the fact that the designers dug this deep into the archives of TMNT baddies is truly commendable.

7. Turtles in Time Tribute

Art from the 'Neon Night-Riders' level of Turtles in Time

This set features more than one tributes to the excellent 1991 arcade classic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time. Fast Forward is notable because the flavor text at the bottom specifically references the "Neon Night Riders" level, a memorable stage where the perspective changes to a third-person view for a skateboard sequence before a boss battle against Krang.

6. Alien Greasers

The Neutrinos from the classic TMNT cartoon

For anyone who grew up watching the original TMNT animated series, the Neutrinos were undoubtedly the height of cool. These three 1950s-style aliens, introduced in the episode "Hot Rodding Teenagers," spoke in high-pitched squeaks, piloted a cool vehicle, and constantly brought chaos. Their inclusion beautifully encapsulates the essence of these fun-loving characters.

5. Toy-Based Tribute

Art card of Leonardo based on the Sewer Samurai action figure

For an longtime TMNT fan, it's gratifying to see a card based on a particular action figure, instead of a cartoon or movie. TMNT's history in the late 20th century was defined by one-off action figures. This special card features a stunning drawing of Leonardo as he appeared in the 1990s "Sewer Samurai" toy line, a look that wasn't featured in any show or film but is now honored here. For collectors, this special art card has standard alternate versions available as well.

4. Tainted Treats

Scene depicting donuts from TMNT II: The Secret of the Ooze

Although Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze was a goofier follow-up, it introduced the mutant villains Tokka and Rahzar. Tainted Treats depicts the climax where the turtles and Professor Jordan Perry create an "mutagen counter-agent", freeze it, and feed them to the creatures. This is a fun piece of movie history captured on cardboard.

3. The Last Ronin's Technique

Art from The Last Ronin comic series

A few cards pay tribute to the powerful 2020 comic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Last Ronin, but The Last Ronin's Technique most powerfully conveys the story's core anguish. The tale follows the last living Turtle fighting in a dystopian New York, wielding all the grief and devastation of witnessing his brothers. It's a dark but deeply resonant story that readers had been waiting for.

2. Turtles Forever

Card featuring multiple versions of the TMNT together

Turtles Forever is like a love letter for longtime fans. While evoking the 2009 crossover movie, it goes further by featuring the live-action of Donatello with his animated brothers. The funny height difference is charming, and while it would have been the perfect place for a musical nod to Coming Out of Their Shells, the card remains as a fantastic celebration of the Turtles' varied history.

1. A Nostalgic Challenge

Box art from the 1989 NES TMNT game

Choosing this card as the best was difficult. The artwork is pulled from the cover of the infamous 1989 NES Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles game, a foundational memory for countless fans. When we got that game, many thought it was a version of the arcade hit. How wrong.

It was a notoriously hard side-scroller that felt nothing like the fun of the cartoon. But, it was our only TMNT game at home initially. Like Splinter taught, I studied and tried to conquer it.

I failed. To this day, I can't defeat it. That dreaded underwater level with the deadly plants was pure torture. Yet, the fun was in the attempt, a feeling this card perfectly evokes.

About the author

Dana Brooks

Jasper is a seasoned gambler and analyst with over a decade of experience in sports betting and casino gaming.

Elite Odds Reels Point

Type to search articles.